Friday 24 October 2008

Rowley and Berman 2000

Great article to get into this braod critique of CSP FP.

really gets at the core of it by asking why researchers are looking at this question anyway - what will it add even if something is found? really just to justify the existance of researchers.

P401 very strong.

single dimensions as proxies

research looking at things csp in 14 different ways. No reason to believe there will be any consistancy. - comparing air pollution with illegal activity?

pg 402

Multiple dimensions

pg 403 goes though a number of different issues relating to why this is also flawed. very strong language at the bottom of 404.

pg 406 Proposes looking at more industry specific stuff. Hooray!

social performance must be defined according to social context p407

excellent article - all the right things - points to moving away from CSP -FP and is very straight about it.

No comments: